Renault Safrane I (B54) (1992 – 1996)

Reliability score : 6.8/10

The Renault Safrane Phase 1 (Generation I - B54) succeeded the legendary Renault 25 in 1992. Designed to compete with German premium sedans, it marked a spectacular leap forward in terms of finish quality, sound insulation, and passive safety. A true rolling lounge, it stood out for its imperial comfort, highly prized « Ergomatic » seats, and exceptional interior space. However, this move upmarket was accompanied by a significant weight gain, penalizing entry-level engines. While the mechanical base is generally very robust, this first phase suffered from numerous « teething problems » related to its complex onboard electronics (voice synthesis, regulated air conditioning) and the chronic fragility of its automatic gearboxes and controlled suspension on high trims (Baccara, Biturbo).

✅ Strengths

⚠️ Weaknesses

🎯 Verdict

The Renault Safrane Phase 1 is today a very endearing « youngtimer », offering comfort worthy of modern limousines for a derisory purchase price. However, its reliability record is mixed. While the engines (especially the 4-cylinder petrol and the 2.1 dT) are monuments of robustness, the nascent electronics of the 90s and the catastrophic fragility of the automatic gearboxes necessitate caution. For a serene purchase, opt for a manual gearbox version, ideally a 2.2 Si or a V6 PRV (with a manual gearbox), with a clear history and functional electronics. Avoid models equipped with unrevised controlled suspension and automatic gearboxes without strict maintenance invoices.